Who Is the Client? When a Youth Club Serves the Parent and Forgets the Player

A youth club needs a coach for one of its older teams. It hires one with a name - a college coach, a résumé families will recognize, something that looks good on the website and in the conversation with parents. A season later the same coach is let go. The reason given: he was "too hard on the kids." Now the club is looking again, and it is determined not to repeat the mistake. The lesson it took away: be more careful about what the parents will like.

I have watched versions of this story for most of my coaching life. It is worth slowing down, because the club believes it learned something. It didn't. It repeated itself.

The film · Who Is the Client?

The same decision, made twice

Hiring a coach because families will like the name, and firing him because families complained, look like opposite decisions: one a yes, one a no. But they are the same decision. Both are made to keep the parent relationship comfortable. Neither one touches the question a development club exists to answer: did the players get better, as players and as people?

Hired for his name and fired for the complaints both lead to one box, keep parents comfortable; a dashed box below, did the players get better, is never asked
Two opposite-looking decisions, one question answered, the other never asked

That is why the lesson the club extracts guarantees the next failure. "Be more careful pleasing parents" is a story built to be defended, not corrected. The next coach will be hired on the same impression and let go on the same pressure, just from a different direction.

"We run it like a corporation"

I have heard club leaders say this with pride. It is exactly the wrong description. A corporation has measurable targets, review cycles, and someone accountable when a hire goes wrong. A club like this one has a brand and a complaints inbox.

Ask the simple questions. What qualified the people who made the hire to judge a coach? What evidence was the dismissal based on? Who took responsibility for the wrong decision? In this pattern the answers are usually: nothing in particular, discomfort rather than evidence, and nobody. Nobody except the coach, who absorbed the whole mistake on his way out the door.

That is not a story about one weak director. It is structure. Put a decent person inside a structure where success has no definition and whoever applies pressure last decides, and you get the same result every time.

Evaluation by impression

Look at how the rest of the club decides things and the same logic is everywhere. Coaches are hired on the appeal of a résumé. They are dismissed on the volume of complaints. Players are selected at tryouts by observation alone: a few coaches watching, forming a view.

Each of those is evaluation by impression. An impression is not nothing. It is a coherent story, built quickly from what stood out. But a coherent story hides what it left out, and when it is the only instrument a club has, nobody ever finds out what that was.

The words that don't land

One detail tells the story better than the rest. Watch a director address a group of players, then ask the players afterward what it was about. Often they can't tell you. The words were spoken; they did not land.

In any healthy system someone would check, because an instruction that doesn't land is wasted. Here nobody checks, because nobody has to. The players are not the client. Their understanding has no line on anyone's evaluation.

What the parent can't see from inside

None of this makes the parents foolish. A parent who chooses a club is making a meaningful decision, and the meaning is real: they want the best environment for their child, and they have done what they can to find it.

But meaning has parts. A decision can be coherent ("this club has a strong name"), purposeful ("I want my child to develop"), and significant ("it matters to our family"), and still be incomplete. The part that goes missing is what a parent cannot see from inside the environment: the club's own interest in the decision. From inside, the coach with a college name looks like an investment in your child. From outside, it may be an investment in your renewal. The same decision means something different when you can step out and see it whole.

What my research helps me see

My doctoral research kept arriving at the same finding: the hardest problems in coaching are structural, not personal. When a club has no single definition of success, every decision is made against whatever pressure is loudest that week. Coaching tenure becomes a customer-satisfaction decision instead of a development decision. And the people who carry the consequences are rarely the people who made the call.

There is one more party in this story, the one with no representation in any of these decisions: the kids. They are not consulted when the coach is hired, not asked when he is fired, and not checked for understanding when the director speaks. Everyone around them is making decisions about their development, and none of those decisions is accountable to it.

Holding both is not a given

It would be easy to read all this as an argument against the business side of a club. It isn't. A club that ignores its finances will not be there next season to develop anyone. The business perspective and the sporting perspective are both legitimate, and they pull against each other. That is a paradox, and a paradox cannot be solved once. It has to be held, decision after decision.

Most people in a club would say they already hold both. They talk about development, and they track renewals. But talking about both is not holding both. Under pressure, people tend to handle the tension in one of three ways, and none of them is holding it. They split it: the business side and the sporting side become separate rooms that never meet. They alternate: development talk in the autumn, parent management in the spring. Or they let one side quietly win while keeping the other side's language. "We run it like a corporation" is usually the third. The business logic won, and it kept the vocabulary of development.

Four panels: split, alternate and capture as ways of not holding the tension; hold, in gold, keeps both pulls in view
Three ways of not holding the tension, and one that is

Holding both is harder. It means keeping the tension in view while making the decision: "families will like this coach's name" and "will the players get better with him?" answered together, without one answer cancelling the other. That is a capacity, not a trait, and nobody receives it with a job title. A coaching license trains one side. A business background trains the other. The capacity to hold both is built only by living inside both long enough to feel each pull as real. The club in this story did not fail because it had a business side. It failed because nobody in the room could hold both at once, and nobody knew that was the missing skill.

What I feel, watching this

I will separate this honestly, because it is not analysis. I don't feel anger at a director. He is inside the same structure, answering the same pressure. What I feel is closer to frustration on behalf of two people: the coach who carried a mistake that wasn't only his, and the player who will meet the next coach chosen the same way and never know why the last one disappeared.

What to do with this

For parents, four questions worth asking any club before you sign, and asking politely, because good clubs will be glad you did:

  1. What is your definition of success for my child's age group? Written down, not described on the spot.
  2. How do you evaluate your coaches, and on what evidence?
  3. How do you assess players at tryouts beyond watching them?
  4. When a decision turns out wrong, who owns it?

For clubs, the work is not complicated, only uncomfortable. Write down what success means, age group by age group, and evaluate coaches against it rather than against the inbox. Add something to tryouts besides impression. And ask the players what landed. Not to hand them the decisions, but because their understanding is the product.

And then the question I apply to everything, including this piece: what did I leave out? Clubs live on family fees, so pleasing parents is not vanity. It is survival, and parents are a legitimate client. The question was never parent or child. It is whether the child's development is the thing anyone in the building is accountable for. A club can serve parents well and still answer that question. The ones in this story never asked it.

References

  • Trajlov (2026), doctoral research on paradox and meaning-making in professional soccer coaching
  • Adaptiverse, "Who Is the Client?" (film) - youtu.be/pA68gh55GZk
  • Adaptiverse, "Meaning Has Four Parts" (film) - youtu.be/wop9ukFcSm4
About Adaptiverse: a development lab for athletes, coaches and organisations

About Adaptiverse

Adaptiverse is a development lab built on a simple idea: more information isn't the answer - meaning is. We help athletes, coaches and organisations make sense of what they live through and turn it into direction. For athletes, that starts with their own story, captured through structured reflections and tested against measurements from tracking and assessment devices. For coaches, teams and organisations, it means making sense of the work, communicating so it lands, and building the conditions to grow. Grounded in doctoral research.

Next
Next

Three Ways of Learning the Game